Most Active Stories
- Some Wampanoag Tribe Members Leery of Plymouth 400 Commemoration
- Every Now and Then... Strange Fish Appear in Cape Cod Waters
- Cape Cod Baseball League All Star Game
- What Plastic Baby Bottles and Climate Change Have in Common
- The Moth Comes to the Tabernacle on Martha's Vineyard on Saturday, August 9th
Wed April 9, 2014
An Education Reporter Puts Himself To The (Standardized) Test
Originally published on Thu May 29, 2014 1:14 pm
What are the two most feared — most reviled — words in the English language?
"Tax day," maybe? Or "traffic jam"?
"Pink slip" still connotes an awful brand of helplessness, even though, I assume, most Americans who get pink-slipped these days never see a pink slip.
No, my vote is for "standardized test."
That's right. You felt it, didn't you? Shivers up the spine. The stab of a No. 2 pencil. And oh! Those monstrous, monotonous bubbles. They may as well be a legion of eyes staring back at your inadequacy.
Well, those dreaded tests we took as kids (and that kids still take) are changing as a result of new Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts and Math. And they're changing radically. Next year, most states will throw out the old tests that varied from state to state in favor of new, Common-Core-aligned tests to measure student performance.
Most of the 44 states that adopted the Core standards have divided into two consortia: Smarter Balanced (note the "d," not the margarine) and PARCC. And it's these consortia that are now hard at work developing new, Common-Core-aligned tests. In fact, both recently began field-testing their tests. What's on them? And how will they be different from the tests kids have been taking for years? Funny you should ask.
The PARCC people were kind enough to post practice tests for anyone with time to kill. They're available for grades 3 through 11 in English Language Arts (sorry, math enthusiasts, you have to wait till April). The tests are available at PARCC's website and are meant to be taken on the computer. Anyone can do it. Since I had just edited a reporter's story out of Vermont, about eighth-graders trying out new Core-inspired learning techniques, I thought I would take the literacy test for eighth-graders.
I won't bore you with my score. What's important here is what's different between these Core-aligned tests and the state tests they will replace.
Wendi Anderson is a senior adviser for English Language Arts/Literacy at PARCC and says that in the old days, some states would ask kids to write an essay like this:
"Imagine you're the principal for the day. What would you do and why?"
I, for one, would mandate marshmallows for every meal and require science classes be taught with kickballs. And that's the problem, says Nancy Doorey, director of programs for the K-12 Center at the nonprofit Educational Testing Service, or ETS.
"The accuracy of what students wrote made no difference at all," Doorey says. "I mean they could literally make up anything in the world and put it in, and it made no difference."
Those tests measured some important composition basics — such as sentence structure and the use of transitions. These new tests can measure those too. They also do something new in many states: They ask kids to read a text closely and to write about it using evidence from the text.
Anderson helped edit the practice test I took, and even she found herself returning, again and again, to the source material.
"I had to go back into the text as I was going through and creating the answer document, because it really does require that close reading," she says. "You can't just read it once and have it down."
Here's another difference between the old tests and new. The reading passages now — for many kids — will be more complex than they're used to, and for some, harder to understand. Doorey says that's because, in the past, some states used passages that were below grade level. The rationale was well-intentioned: to make sure most kids could get through the reading and answer the questions. But Doorey says lowering the bar postponed a hard truth:
"Kids were graduating high school," Doorey says, "and going into community college or the university and finding that the college-level texts are way too difficult."
Even I had a hard time with one section of this eighth-grade practice test. It was actually three passages: one from a real scientific study about elephants cooperating, one from an article about that study, and the third was a video clip of the study in action.
After I watched the video, the test wanted me to write an essay comparing the information in the video to what's in the article and the study. I didn't write it, though. I was busy ... writing this essay comparing information presented in the test itself to everything that came before.
DAVID GREENE, HOST:
Lots more words, lots of written assignments and new standardized tests - all big changes coming with the Common Core. Let's talk about the exams. Many states next year will be using new tests aligned with the Common Core standards. State associations are developing these exams, and there are now practice versions available; which gave Cory Turner, of NPR's education team, a chance to try an exam that one consortium came up with.
CORY TURNER, BYLINE: The consortium is called PARCC, P-A-R-C-C. I'm not going to tell you what it stands for. You won't be tested on it. This practice test is on the computer at PARCC's website. Anybody can take it, and since we just heard Charlotte's story out of Vermont, I thought I'd use the one for eighth-graders. Here's a quick, impressionistic view of the hour I spent on it.
(SOUNDBITE OF BEEPS)
TURNER: What is the meaning of the word sarcasm? Which quotation from the passage best shows additional evidence of the attitude in Part A? OK. I need to read that again. How do the phrases stormed off, float far and invisible nothing...selecting from paragraphs 32 to 39...oh, we're in a new novel here. And it has 47 paragraphs.
I have to use the bathroom. But this is a test. Oh, this is kind of cool. I answer the question by double-clicking on the paragraph that I think answers...no, hold on. No, I don't want that one. I want that one. I am sure an eighth-grader will be better at this than I am. Uh-oh, essay time.
That was only about a third of a test. I won't bore you with my score. What's important is what's different between these Common Core-aligned tests and the state tests they'll replace. Wendi Anderson, of PARCC, says before, some states would ask kids to write an essay like this:
WENDI ANDERSON: Imagine you're the principal for the day. What would you do and why?
TURNER: I, for one, would mandate marshmallows for every meal, and require science classes be taught with kickballs. And that's the problem, says Nancy Doorey. She's director of programs for the K-12 Center at the Educational Testing Service, or ETS.
NANCY DOOREY: The accuracy of what students wrote made no difference at all. I mean they could literally, just make up anything in the world and put it in, and it made no difference.
TURNER: The old tests measured some composition basics, like sentence structure and the use of transitions. These new tests work a lot like those exercises we just heard about in Vermont. They ask kids to write about what they've read, using evidence. Wendi Anderson helped edit the practice test I took.
ANDERSON: But I had to go back into the text, as I was going through and creating the answer document, because it really does require that close reading. You can't just read it once and you have it down.
TURNER: Here's another difference: The passages for many kids will be harder to understand.
ANDERSON: I just don't like the word harder. (Laughter)
TURNER: OK. Let's says the passages will, in many cases, be more complex than kids are used to. Nancy Doorey, of ETS, says that's because in the past, some states intentionally used easier passages to make sure most kids could get through them. But that, she says, just postponed a hard truth.
DOOREY: Kids were graduating from high school, going into community college or the university, and finding that college-level texts are way too difficult.
TURNER: Even I had a hard time with one section of this practice test. It was actually a group of three passages: one from a real scientific study about elephants cooperating, one from an article about the study, and the third was a video clip of the study in action.
(SOUNDBITE OF VIDEO)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: On this video, impatient Elephant Shree Siam fails to wait for his partner. By the time the second elephant gets there, the rope is out of reach and no one gets the reward.
TURNER: The test then wanted me to write an essay comparing the information in that video to what's in the article and in the study. I didn't write it. I was busy writing this essay, comparing information presented in the test itself to everything that came before. Cory Turner, NPR News, Washington.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
GREENE: This is NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.