Ebola Is Rapidly Mutating As It Spreads Across West Africa

Aug 28, 2014
Originally published on August 29, 2014 3:07 pm

For the first time, scientists have been able to follow the spread of an Ebola outbreak almost in real time, by sequencing the virus' genome from people in Sierra Leone.

The findings, published Thursday in the journal Science, offer new insights into how the outbreak started in West Africa and how fast the virus is mutating.

An international team of researchers sequenced 99 Ebola genomes, with extremely high accuracy, from 78 people diagnosed with Ebola in Sierra Leone in June.

The Ebola genome is incredibly simple. It has just seven genes. By comparison, we humans have about 20,000 genes.

"In general, these viruses are amazing because they are these tiny things that can do a lot of damage," says Pardis Sabeti, a computational biologist at Harvard University and the lead author of the study.

Hidden inside Ebola's tiny genome, she says, are clues to how the virus spreads among people — and how to stop it.

"As soon as the outbreak happened and was reported in Guinea," she says, "two members of my lab flew out and worked to set up the diagnostics to pick it up in Sierra Leone."

The team helped to find the first Ebola cases in Sierra Leone. They also immediately shipped diagnostic samples from the patients back to the U.S. and started sequencing the viruses' genomes.

"We had 20 people in my lab working around-the-clock," Sabeti says.

Their furious pace paid off. After just a week or so, the team had decoded gene sequences from 99 Ebola viruses. The data offered a treasure-trove of information about the outbreak.

For starters, the data show that the virus is rapidly accumulating new mutations as it spreads through people. "We've found over 250 mutations that are changing in real time as we're watching," Sabeti says.

While moving through the human population in West Africa, she says, the virus has been collecting mutations about twice as quickly as it did while circulating among animals in the past decade or so.

"The more time you give a virus to mutate and the more human-to-human transmission you see," she says, "the more opportunities you give it to fall upon some [mutation] that could make it more easily transmissible or more pathogenic."

Sabeti says she doesn't know if that's happening yet. But the rapid change in the virus' genome could weaken the tools researchers have to detect Ebola or, potentially, to treat patients.

Diagnostic tests, experimental vaccines and drugs for Ebola — like the one recently used to treat two American patients — are all based on the gene sequences of the virus, Sabeti says. "If the virus is mutating away from the known sequence, that could be important to how these things work."

The new genomic data also indicate that the outbreak started when just one person caught Ebola from an animal. Since then the virus has been spreading through human-to-human transmission — not through humans eating infected bush meat (wild game) as was first thought.

"We're really concerned because a lot of the messaging going around ... is, 'Don't each bush meat; don't eat mango; don't anything that might be in contact with animals,' " she says. "When you see some of those fliers, you're like, 'OK, you just told them not to eat all the main sources of food.' "

So the advice from health officials to avoid bush meat may be doing more harm than good, she says.

Sabeti and the team also compared the Ebola genomes from Sierra Leone with those found in previous outbreaks in Central Africa. Their findings suggest the virus has been circulating around West Africa for about a decade.

"This study is really an impressive tour de force," says virologist Stephen Morse of Columbia University.

But he says he's not surprised the virus is mutating so rapidly.

"We've seen this in a number of infections — SARS for example, influenza and HIV of course," Morse says. "Very often when a new virus is introduced into the human population very suddenly, it will show accelerated rates of evolution."

So should we be concerned that the virus might pick up a mutation that makes it more contagious or deadly?

"That's very hard to say. In most cases, the answer would be 'no,' " Morse says. "But Ebola is obviously a concern and very virulent. I'd say it's too early at this point to speculate on what any mutation or any change, even with rapid evolution, might lead to."

A number of scientists working on the project contracted Ebola while treating patients. "Five of them passed from Ebola," Sabeti says, including Dr. Shiek Humarr Khan. He was Sierra Leone's top virologist and had treated dozens of Ebola patients before catching the virus.

Health workers in Sierra Leone, who talked to NPR in the spring, blamed a lack of proper protective equipment for infections at the government-run hospital in Kenema, where Khan worked.

"The work [treating patients] is just that dangerous," Sabeti says. "Another British nurse at the hospital has just come down with Ebola. You're seeing so many infections going on. It's an extraordinary thing that's going on right now [in Sierra Leone]."

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

We have a story this morning of knowledge that was extremely dangerous to gather, but the knowledge was so important that people were willing to die to get it. It's information about the spread of Ebola in western Africa. Thanks to the perilous work of researchers, scientists for the first time have been able to follow the spread of the virus by sequencing its genetic makeup from people in west Africa. These findings offer new insights into how the outbreak started and how quickly the virus is mutating. NPR's Michaeleen Doucleff reports.

MICHAELEEN DOUCLEFF, BYLINE: Ebola is one of the deadliest viruses on earth and yet it has just seven genes. We humans have about 20,000 genes.

PARDIS SABETI: Within a genome so small, there's a lot of things packed into a very short sequence that's - that are doing this extraordinary amount of damage.

DOUCLEFF: That's Pardis Sabeti. She studies genetics at Harvard. She says that hidden inside Ebola's tiny little genome are clues to how people catch the virus and how to stop it.

SABETI: So as soon as the outbreak happened and was reported in Guinea, two members of my lab flew out and worked to set up the diagnostics to pick it up in Sierra Leone.

DOUCLEFF: That was back in April. Her team helped to find the first 100 or so Ebola cases in Sierra Leone. During the process, several people on the project caught Ebola; five of them died.

SABETI: The work is just that dangerous. Another British nurse at the hospital has just come down with Ebola, and you're seeing so many infections going on right now. And it is an extraordinary thing that is going on right now.

DOUCLEFF: Health workers who NPR talked to back in the spring, they blame a lack of proper protective equipment at government-run hospitals. Sabeti said she wanted to do more than just diagnose Ebola; she wanted to help stop the outbreak. So her team shipped samples back to Boston, and they started sequencing the virus's genome from patients all over Sierra Leone.

SABETI: We had 20 people in my lab working around the clock.

DOUCLEFF: The furious work paid off; after just a week or so, the team had decoded gene sequences from 99 Ebola samples. They just published the data in the journal Science, and the findings offer a treasure trove of information about the outbreak. For starters, the data show that the outbreak started when just one person caught Ebola from animal. Then the virus has been spreading only through people; it's not coming from bush meat or wild game as first thought.

SABETI: We were really concerned 'cause a lot of the messaging that's going out around those populations is, don't eat bush meat, don't eat mangoes, don't eat anything that might be in contact with animals. And when you see some of those flyers, by the end you're like, OK, you just actually told them not to eat all of their main sources of food.

DOUCLEFF: So the advice from health officials to avoid bush meat may be doing more harm than good. The data also show that the virus is rapidly picking up new mutations as it spreads through people.

SABETI: And so we found over, you know, 250 mutations that are just changing as - in sort of real-time as we're watching.

DOUCLEFF: That's about twice as fast as the virus had been mutating while circulating in bats for the last decade or so. Sabeti thinks that might be a cause for concern.

SABETI: The more time you give a virus to mutate and the more opportunities of human-to-human transmission you see, the more opportunities it's going to fall upon something that could make it more easily transmissible or pathogenic.

DOUCLEFF: Sabeti said she doesn't know if that's happening yet. Stephen Morse is a virologist at Columbia University. He says that this study is a technical feat.

STEPHEN MORSE: It really is a tour de force in that they were able to sequence 99 genomes. And that's really quite remarkable in this timeframe.

DOUCLEFF: But he's not surprised the virus is mutating so rapidly.

MORSE: We've seen it in a number of other infections, SARS for example, Influenza, HIV of course. Very often when a new virus is introduced into the human population, very suddenly it will show accelerated rates of evolution.

DOUCLEFF: So should we be concerned that the virus might pick up a mutation that makes it more contagious or deadly?

MORSE: That's very hard to say. In most cases, the answer would probably be no.

DOUCLEFF: But at this stage, he says, we just don't have enough information yet to say exactly what the future of this outbreak will be. Michaeleen Doucleff, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.